Follow us:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • AppStore
  • RSS
Azernews.Az
Saturday January 23 2021
  • Latest
  • Nation
  • World
  • Business
  • Oil & Gas
  • Armenian Aggression
  • Nagorno-karabakh conflict
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Lifestyle
  • Events
  • Healthcare
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Travel
Home
  • Home
  • Nation
  • World
  • Business
  • Oil & Gas
  • Armenian Aggression
  • Nagorno-karabakh conflict
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Lifestyle
  • Events
  • Healthcare
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Travel

Donald Trump wants to raise his own taxes, but would he kill the 1031 real estate break?

28 August 2015 14:41 (UTC+04:00)
2 296

By Bloomberg

Billionaire Donald Trump, who built his fortune in real estate, told Bloomberg Politics this week that he wants to raise his own taxes. One way to do it is a bipartisan proposal that would blow up one of the real estate industry's favorite tax breaks.

The break, known as the like-kind exchange or "1031" for the tax code section it comes from, lets real estate owners sell one piece of property and buy a new one soon afterward without paying any capital gains taxes on the profits from the sale. The result is an ever-increasing pile of deferred capital gains, taxed only whenever there is a final sale or, better yet, never taxed as income at all upon death.

"It was originally meant to really cover a narrow set of transactions," said Lily Batchelder, a former aide to Senate Finance Committee Democrats and to President Barack Obama. "It's grown into this huge loophole, especially for wealthy real estate investors."

Obama has proposed curbing the tax break, arguing that the justification for the 94-year-old provision is outdated because each piece of real estate can be easily valued and then taxed when sold. His plan would limit the benefit to $1 million per taxpayer per year, raising nearly $20 billion for the government over the next decade, according to the Treasury Department. (That's more money, by the way, than the carried interest tax break that's gotten much more public attention and criticism from Trump and leading Democrats.) Former top lawmakers in Congress—Republican Dave Camp and Democrat Max Baucus—went even further than Obama, proposing full repeal of like-kind exchanges for real estate as part of their broader plans to revamp the tax code.

The break distorts economic decision-making by making real estate transactions different from others, but it's been a central part of deals for so long that getting rid of it would be disruptive, both to real estate investors and the industry of intermediaries that exists to facilitate property exchanges. Unsurprisingly, the real-estate industry has spent the past two years building alobbying campaign to justify the break and warn of dire economic consequences if it vanishes. The hand-to-hand combat has occurred mostly behind the scenes in Washington, as lobbyists try to shape a mega-bill on taxes that's going nowhere until 2017 at the earliest. Trump and his company aren't part of the Real Estate Like-Kind Exchange Coalition, according to Jeffrey DeBoer, president and chief executive officer of the Real Estate Roundtable.

"Our tax code is clearly in need of an overhaul, but it should not come at the expense of provisions that fuel economic growth on Main Street," Daniel Goodwin, chief executive officer of Inland Real Estate Group of Companies Inc., said in a statement that called the provision a "core catalyst" for domestic real estate. "A 1031 exchange, for example, enables a business or investor to defer—not dodge—the capital gains tax on an asset sale."

In 2011, U.S. taxpayers deferred more than $33 billionin capital gains through exchanges, according to Internal Revenue Service data. Without the break, they would be more likely to hold onto property, locking themselves into investments for more time to avoid paying the capital gains tax, said Brad Borden, an expert on real estate and taxes at Brooklyn Law School. Property owners would also be more willing to move their investments outside of real estate, because the tax costs of selling for cash and swapping buildings would become equal.

As for Trump, who is leading in polls for the Republican presidential nomination, it's not at all clear what he pays in taxes or how much he benefits from section 1031, because he hasn't released his tax returns. He tends to make long-term real-estate investments, and a good chunk of his income comes from licensing deals that pay him for the use of his name, not necessarily ownership stakes where like-kind exchanges would be an effective strategy. Borden said he'd be "shocked" if some of Trump's entities hadn't used the break.

Still, section 1031 supports the entire real-estate industry, encouraging frequent transactions and creating the environment where Trump thrives. In some cases, it may keep prices lower, because it makes property owners more willing to put their buildings on the market. An industry-backed study released earlier this year said exchanges under section 1031 lead to less debt and that 88 percent of the properties that are exchanged are later sold in taxable transactions. An earlier industry-backed studysaid repeal would lead to more borrowing and reduce gross domestic product by 0.04 percent.

DeBoer said in an e-mailed response to questions that repealing like-kind exchanges would lower real estate values by reducing liquidity and increasing friction in real estate transactions. “Rather than distorting economic decisions, like- kind exchanges remove artificial tax considerations from real estate investments," he said. "Section 1031 prevents the taxation of phantom income. Any taxable gain must be used to acquire the replacement property, otherwise it is taxed immediately.”

The real estate industry's power in Washington—just think of how well the mortgage interest deduction has survived—will make the tax break tough to dislodge. "It would take some gumption, but it's the right policy call and it's a way to treat different investments fairly and in the same manner," said Batchelder, who now teaches at New York University's law school.

Trump will release more details on his tax plan over the next few weeks, Hope Hicks, a campaign spokeswoman, said in an e-mail. She didn't say whether Trump has used like-kind exchanges.

Of course, there are other, more straightforward ways that Trump can raise his own taxes. He can increase marginal tax rates. He can adopt a favorite Republican proposal and end the tax deduction for state and local income and property taxes, which disproportionately benefits residents of high-tax states such as New York. He could also raise estate taxes or limit the maneuvers the wealthiest few can use to minimize that tax. But Trump thrives on drama, and none of those options would be nearly as dramatic as attacking his own industry.

Category News

President Ilham Aliyev: Activities of parliament related to social sphere should be very active <span class="color_red">[PHOTO]</span>

President Ilham Aliyev: Activities of parliament related to social sphere should be very active [PHOTO]

14 March 2020 22:41
Hermes holds talks with actress Jane Birkin following complaint

Hermes holds talks with actress Jane Birkin following complaint

28 August 2015 18:30
Congress's fight over Iran deal is over

Congress's fight over Iran deal is over

28 August 2015 18:12
Russia said to move closer to profit-based tax for oil industry

Russia said to move closer to profit-based tax for oil industry

28 August 2015 17:46
What New Orleans needs to change 10 years later

What New Orleans needs to change 10 years later

28 August 2015 17:34
Printing currency goes haywire in Venezuela

Printing currency goes haywire in Venezuela

28 August 2015 17:14
Index futures fall as stocks poised to end two-day relief rally

Index futures fall as stocks poised to end two-day relief rally

28 August 2015 17:13
Dollar pares weekly gain as stock markets swing back to losses

Dollar pares weekly gain as stock markets swing back to losses

28 August 2015 16:06
China bonds cap biggest weekly gain since April after rate cuts

China bonds cap biggest weekly gain since April after rate cuts

28 August 2015 15:22
Euro-area confidence unexpectedly rises amid market tumult

Euro-area confidence unexpectedly rises amid market tumult

28 August 2015 14:58
  • Latest
  • Popular
22 January 19:50 • Azercell is always leading with its exemplary service quality
22 January 19:38 • Azerbaijan shows footage from Yukhari Abdurrakhmanli village of Fuzuli [PHOTO/VIDEO]
22 January 19:27 • Demand for notes of Central Bank of Azerbaijan exceeds supply
22 January 19:15 • Azerbaijan developing employment programs for future residents of liberated lands [PHOTO]
22 January 19:00 • Changeable cloudy expected on Saturday
22 January 18:50 • Azerbaijani gymnasts to take part in European Championships in Switzerland
22 January 18:39 • Tutoring activity may be resumed in Azerbaijan soon - minister
22 January 18:26 • Education minister talks epidemiological situation in Azerbaijan
22 January 18:15 • Russia bans import of tomatoes from more Azerbaijani producers
22 January 18:00 • Azerbaijan's PASHA Bank talks government initiatives for restoring liberated territories
22 January 17:53 • All preventive measures to be taken in connection with COVID-19 at Azerbaijani schools
22 January 17:45 • Minister talks possible date of kindergartens opening in Azerbaijan
22 January 17:38 • Azerbaijan-Turkmenistan co-op development serves economic well-being of region - MP
22 January 17:27 • Azerbaijan shows footage from Gargabazar village of Fuzuli district [PHOTO/VIDEO]
22 January 17:26 • Azerbaijani President declared Nagorno-Karabakh status issue as left in past - MFA's comment on European Parliament's resolution
22 January 17:16 • SOCAR Aviation starts supplying fuel to Izmir's airport
22 January 17:10 • Armenian opposition rallying in front of parliament building
22 January 17:04 • Azerbaijan establishes Agency for Development of Economic Zones
22 January 17:03 • UK can help Azerbaijan to demine liberated lands - ambassador
22 January 17:00 • Azerbaijan launches criminal case against two foreigners fighting in Karabakh war
22 January 12:50 • President Aliyev: Azerbaijani-Turkmen joint energy accord historic [UPDATE]
22 January 17:00 • Azerbaijan launches criminal case against two foreigners fighting in Karabakh war
22 January 19:50 • Azercell is always leading with its exemplary service quality
22 January 19:27 • Demand for notes of Central Bank of Azerbaijan exceeds supply
22 January 14:33 • Results of Second Karabakh War hard to accept for Armenia, says Russian expert
22 January 19:38 • Azerbaijan shows footage from Yukhari Abdurrakhmanli village of Fuzuli [PHOTO/VIDEO]
22 January 15:47 • Baku Slavic University, Russian Cultural Center to expand ties [PHOTO]
22 January 13:00 • ADY Express starts transport of cargo in covered wagons via BTK
22 January 13:17 • Mine Action Agency specialist wounded in mine blast in Jabrayil
22 January 16:17 • Education in Azerbaijani schools to begin in stages from February 1
22 January 10:59 • Investments in Azerbaijan’s oil, gas sector up in 2020
22 January 19:15 • Azerbaijan developing employment programs for future residents of liberated lands [PHOTO]
22 January 11:38 • Pashinyan's confession on Shusha destroys absurd statements of Armenian officials
22 January 19:00 • Changeable cloudy expected on Saturday
22 January 12:35 • Azerbaijani MP talks rational bases for positive outlook on country's economy for 2021
22 January 17:26 • Azerbaijani President declared Nagorno-Karabakh status issue as left in past - MFA's comment on European Parliament's resolution
22 January 12:17 • "Diary of a Madman" to be staged in Baku
22 January 12:00 • Azerbaijani, French FMs mull Karabakh peace deal, ties
22 January 16:35 • Prices for Azerbaijani oil slightly decrease
22 January 10:38 • Memory of Black January martyrs commemorated [PHOTO/VIDEO]
See more
AzerNews Newspaper
AzerNews
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • RSS

Information

About us Contacts Advertising Azernews In Print

News Archive

© 2021 AzerNews. All rights reserved