Follow us:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • AppStore
  • RSS
Azernews.Az
Friday April 16 2021
  • Latest
  • Nation
  • World
  • Business
  • Oil & Gas
  • Armenian Aggression
  • Nagorno-karabakh conflict
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Lifestyle
  • Events
  • Healthcare
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Travel
Home
  • Home
  • Nation
  • World
  • Business
  • Oil & Gas
  • Armenian Aggression
  • Nagorno-karabakh conflict
  • Editorial
  • Analysis
  • Lifestyle
  • Events
  • Healthcare
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Travel

Oil prices are set by traders' invisible hand

19 February 2015 11:00 (UTC+04:00)
2 953

By Bloomberg View

Bank analysts are predicting the oil rally of recent weeks isn't going to last. It's important, though, to reflect on why the rally happened in the first place. It was never about supply and demand as such, but about the market's perception of where they were going. If oil prices head south again, that, too, will be a result of guesswork. Traders should know there is an element of self-fulfilling prophecy -- for the long term, as well as the short term -- in their pronouncements about today's oil market.

Crude oil prices started falling last September. Brent oil crashed by almost 55 percent by mid-January, but it's up about 32 percent since:

Bloomberg

Yet nothing in particular happened in these five weeks to cause this upturn. There have been no bigger than average supply disruptions in the Middle East, no oil embargo against Russia, no reduction in U.S. shale output as a result of Saudi Arabia's price war. In fact, in the week that ended on February 6, the U.S. produced 9.226 million barrels of crude per day -- the most since the U.S. Energy Information Administration started taking weekly measurements in 1983.

To be sure, the rally was driven by data. There were announcements from large energy companies about falling profits, job cuts (IHS Global predicts up to 40,000 of these industry- wide unless prices rebound) and investment reductions. Then there was the falling U.S. rig count, provided by oil services company Baker Hughes -- a scary chart for any data-loving investor:

Baker Hughes

Together, the news suggested an impending Saudi victory over the U.S. shale industry that would force the latter to reduce output and thus end the global oil glut. Hence the rise in prices.

Now, a narrative pushback is beginning. Investors are learning that rig counts have diminishing value as an indicator. The rigs being idled are the least efficient vertical ones, while the more productive horizontal ones are increasing their share. A Bloomberg Intelligence report published yesterday talked of "more efficient rig deployment and unique well completion designs" underpinning the U.S. shale industry's surprising resilience.

Meanwhile, there are new numbers to obsess over: the U.S. has record output and developed nations have growing crude stocks. Here's another chart calling for knee-jerk action -- U.S. commercial crude inventories have reached a record level of 417.9 million barrels:

U.S. Department of Energy

The frantic search for useful indicators isn't just a myopic trading strategy. It's also affecting long term trends. The current crude price level makes some of the provisionally scrapped investment projects look attractive again, but if speculators drive it down because they decide to watch oil stocks rather than drill counts, the projects will look bad by the time the next corporate investment committee meeting comes around.

Everything takes a long time in the oil industry. Investment cuts begin affecting production years after they are made. The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries pointed out in its February report that one of the reasons the falling rig count is not yet affecting output is that there's at least a three-month time lag between drilling and well completion. Unlike finance, oil extraction is done with heavy equipment and in constant combat with the forces of nature.

In the oil market, by contrast, nothing takes a long time. It's a financial market in which the only things that really matter are the dance of digits on a computer screen and the quick minds of people watching them.

People involved in the oil business often resent that. OPEC has long complained about the speculative nature of today's markets. In a recent Financial Times opinion piece, Igor Sechin, chief executive of Russia's state-owned oil major, Rosneft, wrote that "In today’s distorted oil markets prices do not reflect reality. They are driven instead by financial speculation, which outweighs the real-life factors of supply and demand. Financial markets tend to produce economic bubbles, and those bubbles tend to burst." He suggested that financial regulators make sure at least 10 or 15 percent of all oil trades actually involve supplies of that pungent black liquid rather than "electronic tokens or pieces of paper."

Regulatory wheels, however, turn just as slowly as industrial ones do, and there is no particular reason why governments in the West would want to interfere with the oil market now that low prices are about to benefit most of the developed world -- and hurt the likes of Russia and Venezuela. That leaves even the best-informed oilmen quarreling about price forecasts.

Sechin wrote in his article that if low prices keep depressing investment, "eventually" the price will climb to $90 to $110 per barrel. By contrast, Mikhail Fridman, a Russian billionaire who, two years ago, sold his oil assets to Rosneft, suggested in his own Financial Times commentary that low oil prices were the new reality -- and used much the same arguments to back that up as Sechin employed in justifying his $110 prediction. What determines the price, Fridman wrote, is "mere perception". Of course, that logic can work in either direction.

Perceptions are created, to a large extent, by media. I have been careful not to give preference to any perception in this column so far, though I do believe that countries such as Saudi Arabia and Russia have a higher tolerance for prolonged periods of cheap oil than do energy firms such as the U.S. shale operators and service companies. That gives them a built-in advantage in the price war that started last year, and another speculative panic leading to $30 or even $20 oil is not going to erode it. On the other hand, the market for sustainable energy has even more staying power than these countries do. In the long term, major technological trends and national interests are going to determine supply and demand on the oil market.

But the price of oil is another matter. That's going to depend on the headlines that reflect those national interests and technological advances -- or perhaps some new short term factors of the day. Traders rarely lack explanations for the numbers that skip across their screens.

Category News

President Ilham Aliyev: Activities of parliament related to social sphere should be very active <span class="color_red">[PHOTO]</span>

President Ilham Aliyev: Activities of parliament related to social sphere should be very active [PHOTO]

14 March 2020 22:41
Hermes holds talks with actress Jane Birkin following complaint

Hermes holds talks with actress Jane Birkin following complaint

28 August 2015 18:30
Congress's fight over Iran deal is over

Congress's fight over Iran deal is over

28 August 2015 18:12
Russia said to move closer to profit-based tax for oil industry

Russia said to move closer to profit-based tax for oil industry

28 August 2015 17:46
What New Orleans needs to change 10 years later

What New Orleans needs to change 10 years later

28 August 2015 17:34
Printing currency goes haywire in Venezuela

Printing currency goes haywire in Venezuela

28 August 2015 17:14
Index futures fall as stocks poised to end two-day relief rally

Index futures fall as stocks poised to end two-day relief rally

28 August 2015 17:13
Dollar pares weekly gain as stock markets swing back to losses

Dollar pares weekly gain as stock markets swing back to losses

28 August 2015 16:06
China bonds cap biggest weekly gain since April after rate cuts

China bonds cap biggest weekly gain since April after rate cuts

28 August 2015 15:22
Euro-area confidence unexpectedly rises amid market tumult

Euro-area confidence unexpectedly rises amid market tumult

28 August 2015 14:58
  • Latest
  • Popular
15 April 19:10 • Russian, Belarus presidents discuss situation in Karabakh via phone
15 April 18:50 • Turkey sees decline in number of real estates bought by Azerbaijani citizens in 1Q2021
15 April 18:43 • Opening of Zangazur corridor to expand Azerbaijan's transit potential, says expert
15 April 18:27 • +21 °C expected in Baku
15 April 18:15 • Defense Ministry shares video from Zangilan's Agh Oyuq village [VIDEO]
15 April 18:00 • PM says Armenian army to be reformed within Russian army
15 April 17:50 • Italian senator: Why Armenia destroyed Aghdam if it considered it to be its own? [PHOTO]
15 April 17:42 • Azerbaijan announces commissioning date for 'Victory Road' to liberated Shusha [PHOTO]
15 April 17:30 • Azerbaijan sees increase in prices for silver, platinum, palladium
15 April 17:14 • Miss & Mister Azerbaijan 2020 named [PHOTO]
15 April 16:53 • Azerbaijani oil prices continue to rise
15 April 16:44 • Azerbaijan confirms 2,317 more COVID-19 cases, 2,109 recoveries
15 April 16:38 • Shusha Musical Theater's actors awarded [PHOTO]
15 April 16:15 • Turkey hopes US won't recognize so-called "Armenian genocide" - Turkish FM
15 April 16:05 • SOCAR implemented investment projects worth $13bn in Turkey
15 April 16:00 • Azerbaijan boosts electricity production in March
15 April 15:42 • War Trophy Park in Baku symbolizes heroic Azerbaijani people's triumphant victory - MP [PHOTO]
15 April 15:15 • Azerbaijani PM meets outgoing Turkish envoy
15 April 14:53 • National judokas to compete in Lisbon
15 April 14:42 • Group of journalists visit Azerbaijan’s Aghdam district [PHOTO]
15 April 17:14 • Miss & Mister Azerbaijan 2020 named [PHOTO]
15 April 14:33 • Azerbaijan, IFC sign MoU on offshore wind energy resources [PHOTO]
15 April 11:15 • Baku urges French envoy in Armenia to be responsible in war-related remarks
15 April 16:05 • SOCAR implemented investment projects worth $13bn in Turkey
15 April 13:39 • Aliyev: Azerbaijan focused on confidence-building measures, joint regional projects [UPDATE]
15 April 13:18 • UN concludes field mission to Azerbaijan's war-affected regions
15 April 09:45 • Azerbaijan's First VP gives instructions in regards to Tunar Bagırov suffering from SMA
15 April 10:47 • Azerbaijan's religious board launches virtual TV channel in Ramadan
15 April 12:00 • Azerbaijan opens new military unit in liberated Gubadli
15 April 16:00 • Azerbaijan boosts electricity production in March
15 April 17:30 • Azerbaijan sees increase in prices for silver, platinum, palladium
15 April 18:43 • Opening of Zangazur corridor to expand Azerbaijan's transit potential, says expert
15 April 15:15 • Azerbaijani PM meets outgoing Turkish envoy
15 April 09:30 • Heydar Aliyev Palace to expand cultural ties [PHOTO]
15 April 11:33 • National History Museum displays unique exhibits [PHOTO]
15 April 12:55 • Armenian PM says about 4,000 soldiers killed in Karabakh war
15 April 16:15 • Turkey hopes US won't recognize so-called "Armenian genocide" - Turkish FM
15 April 17:50 • Italian senator: Why Armenia destroyed Aghdam if it considered it to be its own? [PHOTO]
15 April 10:15 • More apartments given to war-affected citizens [PHOTO]
15 April 18:00 • PM says Armenian army to be reformed within Russian army
See more
AzerNews Newspaper
AzerNews
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • RSS

Information

About us Contacts Advertising Azernews In Print

News Archive

© 2021 AzerNews. All rights reserved