Europe to Limit Banker Bonuses
STRASBOURG - The European Parliament agreed to what officials
described as the world's strictest rules on bankers' bonuses,
capping big cash awards across the European Union in time for 2010
payouts.
The new law, agreed upon Wednesday, will limit upfront cash to 30%
of a banker's total bonus and to 20% in the case of very large
bonuses. Between 40% to 60% of bonuses will have to be deferred for
at least three years and can be clawed back if the recipient's
investments perform badly. At least half will have to be paid in
stock or "contingent capital," meaning it won't be paid if the bank
hits difficulties.
The law represents the latest victory in a global regulatory push
to rein in the bonuses that some critics see as helping stoke the
financial crisis. Officials said the law is likely to be formally
adopted at a meeting of EU finance ministers next week, allowing it
to come into effect at all banks operating in the European Union
before this year's bonus season
The rules "send a strong political message: There will be no return
to business as usual," said Internal Market Commissioner Michel
Barnier. "Banks will need to change radically their practices and
the mentality that have led in many cases to excessive risk-taking
and contributed to the financial crisis."
In the U.S., despite much discussion about banker bonuses, there
have been no moves to explicitly limit cash bonuses. The Federal
Reserve has new, broad authority to tell banks how they should pay
their employees, but there are no hard caps or taxes on bonuses.
More-explicit restrictions could emerge as regulators write
specific regulations on banks.
The new rules effectively codify what has become common practice
among banks, which have sought to fend off harsher regulations by
limiting cash payouts and tying banker pay more closely to
long-term performance of the companies. Critics say big cash
bonuses were one cause of the financial crisis, because they
encouraged bankers to take big risks amid the knowledge that they
would get paid even if their investments soured in the future.
Still, the law doesn't put a cap on total pay, although European
banking supervisors will set guidelines later this year on the
maximum proportions of base salaries that may be awarded as
bonuses. And an unintended consequence of the law is that it could
lead to higher base salaries as banks look to attract talent with
the promise of more guaranteed money.
European officials said the rules will apply to banks and
investment firms and not hedge-fund managers - though they would
apply to investment firms that manage hedge-fund assets. Members of
the parliament are likely to attempt to introduce rules curbing
payouts for hedge-fund managers in legislation due later this
year.
The law also requires banks to hold a minimum amount of capital to
ensure they are covering risk from their trading books and complex
securitized investments, such as mortgage-backed securities. The
aim is to avoid a repeat of losses like those seen during the
financial crisis that escalated in late 2008. The capital
requirements would take effect in 2012.
The law is telling banks "hold more capital, get your priorities
right," said Arlene McCarthy, the parliament member who steered the
legislation through the assembly. "We want banks to focus not on
their own pay and perks, but more on lending and support to
economic recovery," she added.
Forcing banks by law to stretch out bonuses over several years will
be good news for European banks because it will limit competition
among them, says Alex Kleanthous, a partner at Gannons, a London
law firm. "It's like the smoking ban on airlines. They all wanted
to have a smoking ban, but nobody wanted to be the first to do it,"
he said.
The banks' biggest concern would be if financial centers in other
cities, such as New York or Singapore, had less restrictive laws -
which could lure some top bankers away or prove more attractive to
recruits, he says.
In the U.K., which is home to Europe's largest financial markets,
officials said that the law would extend more broadly what had
already been codified by British regulators. At least, the law will
put London on level ground with other European cities, if not other
financial centers, in terms of banker pay.
The U.K. stood largely alone in regulating compensation despite a
commitment from the leaders of the Group of 20 big economies to
keep remuneration in check. In a statement last September after
they met in Pittsburgh, G-20 leaders agreed "to implement strong
international compensation standards aimed at ending practices that
lead to excessive risk-taking." Before parliament's move Wednesday,
however, efforts to put in place global standards have largely
stagnated.
In another vote Wednesday, the European Parliament emphasized its
opposition to proposals from individual EU governments that want to
keep significant national control over a planned overhaul of
official supervision of the EU's financial sector.
With an overwhelming majority, it voted to give European
supervisory agencies - due to be created at the start of next year
- more powers over national banks, financial markets and insurance
firms than many governments would tolerate.
The parliament also voted to locate new agencies to supervise
banks, markets and the insurance business in Frankfurt alone,
instead of in London, Brussels and Paris as EU governments had
envisaged.
Some officials said the parliament's position that the agencies
should be located in Frankfurt is likely to be negotiated away in
talks among the parliament, governments and the European
Commission. The talks are unlikely to be concluded before September
or October, when the different approaches to financial-sector
regulation may be resolved.
Here we are to serve you with news right now. It does not cost much, but worth your attention.
Choose to support open, independent, quality journalism and subscribe on a monthly basis.
By subscribing to our online newspaper, you can have full digital access to all news, analysis, and much more.
You can also follow AzerNEWS on Twitter @AzerNewsAz or Facebook @AzerNewsNewspaper
Thank you!